love is in the air

Fall for our delicious and wholesome desserts, or give the gift of Sensible Bakery to a special someone

Valentine's Treats >>

Filter:

Category
0 selected Reset
Dietary Restrictions Match all
0 selected Match all Reset

93 products

Stack of chocolate chip muffins with a crumb topping, arranged on a light surface.
Chocolate chip muffins with a crumb topping, one muffin broken open to show the fluffy interior, arranged on a light surface with additional muffins in the background.
$5.35
Chocolate Chip Muffin
close up of slices of a coconut loaf with blueberries throughout and a vibrant purple blueberry icing garnished with shredded coconut
close up of slices of a coconut loaf with blueberries throughout and a vibrant purple blueberry icing garnished with shredded coconut
$49.00
Blueberry Coconut Loaf
Carrot walnut loaf topped with creamy frosting and crushed walnuts displayed on a decorative plate.
Carrot walnut loaf topped with creamy frosting and crushed walnuts, with a slice cut and served on a decorative plate, showcasing its moist texture.
$49.00
Carrot Walnut Loaf
Sliced lemon almond loaf cake with white frosting on top, garnished with almonds, on a plate with a napkin and a candle in the background.
stacked slices of lemon almond loaf with frosting and sliced almonds on top
$49.00
Lemon Almond Loaf
A banana walnut loaf cake with a slice cut out, alongside fresh bananas and walnuts on a grey background.
A banana walnut loaf cake with a slice cut out, alongside fresh bananas and walnuts on a grey background.
$49.00
Banana Walnut Loaf
A slice of marble loaf cake on a white plate, showcasing the intricate swirl pattern of chocolate and vanilla, with the rest of the loaf visible in the background.
A front view of a whole marble loaf cake, highlighting the marbled chocolate and vanilla interior, topped with a generous drizzle of dark chocolate ganache.
$49.00
Marble Loaf
Whole apple pie with a lattice crust on a wooden board, surrounded by a striped cloth, plates, and cinnamon sticks.
Slice of apple pie on a plate with the rest of the pie in the background and plates and cinnamon sticks around it
On Sale from $5.95
Apple Pie Lattice
Up to -87%
Stack of oatmeal brookies on a white plate with a single piece on the side and chocolate chunks scattered.
Two oatmeal brookies on a marble surface surrounded by chocolate chunks, oats, vanilla extract, oil, cinnamon sticks, ground cinnamon, brown sugar, and flour.
From $5.35
Oatmeal Brookie
Whole Oreo cheesecake topped with whipped cream and crushed Oreo cookies, placed on a wooden cake stand with whole and half Oreo cookies scattered around.
Top-down view of an Oreo cheesecake, covered with whipped cream and generously sprinkled with crushed Oreo cookies on a dark, textured background.
On Sale from $7.42
Oreo Cheesecake
Up to -92%
Slice of coconut custard pie on a decorative plate, with the rest of the pie in the background on a wooden stand.
Two slices of coconut custard pie with ingredients including coconut flakes, tofu cubes, vanilla beans, and flour on a marble surface.
On Sale from $5.75
Coconut Custard Pie
Up to -29%
Banana walnut cakewith decorative swirls of frosting and whole walnuts, rolled in crushed walnuts.
Layered banana walnut cake topped with walnuts and finely chopped nuts, placed on a cake stand with a slice being lifted to reveal the moist interior.
On Sale from $7.50
Banana Walnut Cake
Up to -92%
Mini cranberry apple pie with a crumb topping, served with a fork on a dark blue cloth, surrounded by fresh cranberries.
Mini cranberry apple pie with ingredients: apple slices, cranberries, nutmeg, flour, butter, cinnamon sticks, and brown sugar on a marble surface.
On Sale from $5.99
Cranberry Apple Pie
Up to -33%
A close up of the top of a vanilla frosted cake with "happy birthday jonathan" written in brown icing and decorative dollops of white icing topped with a crushed nut garnish. The side of the cake is rolled in crushed nuts.
A decorated cake with the words 'Twenty four' written on it in icing, surrounded by pink frosting dollops on a white background. The side of the cake is rolled in pink and white sprinkles.
$8.00
Custom Writing
Blueberry lemon scones with lemon glaze and blueberries on a white plate with a blurred background
Stack of blueberry lemon scones with a lemon glaze on a white plate, surrounded by blueberries.
$4.99
Blueberry Lemon Scone
Chocolate chip cookies on a white plate with a yellow textured mat underneath
Two cookies on a plate with a coffee cup labeled 'Sensible Fabrics' in the background.
$5.25
Chocolate Chip Cookie
An open white gift box with colorful floral patters displaying an assortment of packaged food items, including an oatmeal brookie, an apricot almont bar, a walnut chocolate brownie, a german chocolate brownie, an oatmeal chocolate cookie, and a cookie crumble cookie
An open white gift box with colorful floral patters displaying an assortment of packaged food items, including an oatmeal brookie, an apricot almont bar, a walnut chocolate brownie, a german chocolate brownie, an oatmeal chocolate cookie, and a cookie crumble cookie
From $44.95
Gift Box
Large carrot walnut bundt cake with creamy frosting and crushed walnuts on a scalloped-edge cake board, featuring intricate frosting designs
Close-up of a carrot walnut bundt cake with intricate frosting design and crushed walnuts.
$59.00
Carrot Walnut Bundt
Close-up of a blueberry crumb muffin, broken in half to reveal the moist interior with visible blueberries, set on a small place surrounded by a cup of coffee and more muffins in the background.
Top view of a blueberry crumb muffin broken in half, revealing the moist interior, set on a small plate surrounded by a cup of coffee, cinnamon sticks, vanilla beans on a light textured background.
$5.25
Blueberry Crumb Muffin
A layered pink velvet cake with white and red frosting decorations, placed on a wooden stand.
Close up of a pink velvet cake with pink frosting with decorative pink hearts and pink and white frosting decorations
From $69.00
Inside Out Pink Velvet Cake
Mini apple crumb pies on a white surface with cinnamon sticks and vanilla beans
Two slices of mini apple pie on a marble surface with apple slices, lemon wedge, vanilla bean, and cinnamon sticks.
On Sale from $5.99
Apple Crumb Pie
Up to -29%