A mini pumpkin pie with a slice cut out, placed on a white plate, showing a fork holding a piece of pie, with more pies in the background.
Three mini pumpkin pies with a golden crust and smooth pumpkin filling, placed on a dark, textured background.
Various mini pumpkin pies, some sliced and some whole, arranged on black trays and white plates, with forks and a striped cloth on a marble surface.
A slice of pumpkin pie on a white plate with a blue pattern, with the whole pie in a cast iron skillet and mini pumpkins on a marble surface decorated with blue cloth and orange flowers.
Ingredients for mini pumpkin pies including pumpkin puree, butter, coconut cream, flour, brown sugar, nutmeg, vanilla bean, and cinnamon sticks on a marble surface.

Pumpkin Pie

$36.00
Size
Quantity

Classic Pumpkin Pie made with wholesome ingredients for you and your loved ones. A good source of fiber, soy-free, nut-free, and low in calories.

  • Shelf-life 5 days.
  • Please Refrigerate.
  • All pies are labeled with ingredients and nutritional facts

 

Ingredients 

Pumpkin, light brown sugar, homemade organic oat milk, organic maple syrup, certified gluten-free corn starch, organic ceylon cinnamon, organic ginger, organic cloves, vanilla extract, organic nutmeg.

Crust: Certified gluten-free white rice flour, certified gluten-free tapioca flour, organic oat flour, certified gluten-free potato starch, organic cane sugar, organic vegan butter, organic xanthan gum, water, sea salt. 

Allergen: Contains no major allergens. 

Learn more about on-site allergens

Nutritional Facts

Shipping and Delivery

We offer NYC local delivery, pickup services, and nationwide shipping. Certain items, like cakes and pies, require next-day delivery, so regions such as the West Coast and Midwest may experience limitations.

Antioxidant

Pumpkin

Protein

Great 

Omega 3 & 9

Healthy Fats

Key features

Vegans welcome! Plant-Based/Dairy Free (no eggs, milk, or butter)

100% natural Ingredients, no chemicals, no preservatives

Baker's dozen — this one is popular, so extras are donated weekly to our local NYC homeless shelter, reducing waste and nurturing our community

Crafted with care over the last 30 years and spanning two generations.

Mass produced food is often laden with preservatives, artificial ingredients, and designed to cut costs- not here! Quality is our first priority. SENSIBLE products are made with love by humans for humans. No robots allowed!

Sustainably packaged with repurposed food-safe boxes

Certified Gluten-free

Our kitchen is fully gluten-free. If you’re Celiac, rest assured we’ve eliminated the risk of cross-contamination. Even without allergy symptoms, you might find that removing gluten creates space for healthier foods in your diet. Replacing traditional flours with almond, oat, tapioca, and coconut enhances flavor and nutritional value. It’s always best to speak with a professional before making major dietary changes. Consult a registered dietitian to ensure your diet remains well-rounded.

Bakers Dozen

We serve our local homeless and migrant shelters and other non-profits on a rotating basis. Groups that promote healthy eating habits and social justice are most important to us. We're currently supporting Bake Sale for Palestine and our nearby community garden. We provide baked goods, funding, and volunteer hours as well.

Pumpkin Antioxidant

Pumpkins represent the essence of fall! They’re loaded with vitamins A and C, keeping your skin glowing, vision sharp, and immune system strong. Plus, with plenty of fiber, pumpkins aid digestion, stabilize blood sugar, and help you stay full. Rich in antioxidants, they also fight inflammation and support heart health.

Viewed with

Vanilla berry muffin topped with powdered sugar and mixed berries, resting on its side with more muffins and berries in the background.

Vanilla Berry Bliss Muffin

$5.35
0
Banana blueberry muffin surrounded by blueberries, bananas, and cinnamon sticks on a white marble background.

Banana Blueberry Muffin

$4.65
0
Top view of lemon zucchini protein muffins on a white surface. Some muffins are whole, while others are cut in half to reveal a moist, crumbly texture filled with blueberries.

Lemon Zucchini Protein Muffin

$4.99
0
Close-up of a blueberry crumb muffin, broken in half to reveal the moist interior with visible blueberries, set on a small place surrounded by a cup of coffee and more muffins in the background.

Blueberry Crumb Muffin Gluten Free

$4.65
0

At Sensible, we turn guilty pleasures into healthy snacks with simple, fresh, sustainably sourced food. We advocate for an ingredient-conscious lifestyle that puts the health of people and the planet first.

Learn more