Leavening Guide

Connect with us!

All percentages used in this guide are baker’s %- that means its relative to the total amount of flour rather than total amount of all ingredients.

Baseline
100% flour = 120 g ≈ 1 cup
(All percentages scale to any batch size.)

Total chemical leavener (baking powder + baking soda) rarely exceeds 3% of flour.
If texture problems persist above this level, fix hydration, fat, sugar, or bake profile — not leavening.

Percent By Product Catagory

Cakes (Layer, Sheet, Snack Cakes)

Baking powder: 1.5–2.0%
(≈ 1 tsp | ~4 g)

Baking soda: 0–0.2% (must add acid)
(≈ 0–⅛ tsp | 0–0.15 g)

This will give a soft crumb and controlled rise. If there is doming followed by a collapse, there is too much leavener.

Muffins

Baking powder: 2.0–3.0%
(≈ 1–1½ tsp | 4–6 g)

Baking soda: 0.2–0.5%
(≈ ⅛–¼ tsp | 0.3–0.6 g)

Muffins tolerate more lift than cakes, and can use more leavener.

Quick Breads (Banana, Pumpkin, Loaf)

Baking powder: 1.5–2.5%
(≈ ¾–1¼ tsp | 3–5 g)

Baking soda: 0.4–0.8%
(≈ ¼–½ tsp | 0.5–1 g)

Bakes containing fruit purée, brown sugar, and cocoa require baking soda.

Scones/Biscuits

Baking powder: 2.5–3.0%
(≈ 1–1¼ tsp | 5–6 g)

Baking soda: 0–0.3% (must add acid)
(≈ 0–⅛ tsp | 0–0.2 g)

These bakes will have a strong early lift. Structure comes from dough handling, not soda.

Cookies

Baking soda: 0.4–0.8%
(≈ ¼–½ tsp | 0.5–1 g)

Baking powder: 0–0.5% (optional)
(≈ 0–¼ tsp | 0–1 g)

Baking soda controls spread and browning. Baking powder is used only for thicker or cakier cookies.

Cheesecakes (Baked)

Baking powder: 0–0.5% (often none)
(≈ 0–¼ tsp | 0–1 g)

Baking soda: 0%

Structure comes from eggs and proteins, not chemical leaveners.

Waffles/Pancakes

Baking powder: 2.0–3.0%
(≈ 1–1½ tsp | 4–6 g)

Baking soda: 0.2–0.4% (acidic dairy)
(≈ ⅛–¼ tsp | 0.3–0.5 g)

Fast cooking time requires immediate gas release.

Cake Donuts

Baking powder: 2.0–2.5%
(≈ 1–1¼ tsp | 4–5 g)

Baking soda: 0.2–0.4%
(≈ ⅛–¼ tsp | 0.3–0.5 g)

Tender but sturdy crumb.

Leavener Troubleshooting

Not Browning Enough

Meaning:
Too low of a pH leads to insufficient baking soda activity.

Fix:
Increase baking soda by +0.1–0.2% OR replace 0.3% baking powder with 0.1% baking soda.

Check before adjusting:
Sugar level and bake temperature.

GF note
Let batter rest longer before adjusting soda. Under-hydrated GF batters brown poorly even with correct soda.

Too Dark/Bitter/Soapy

Meaning:
The pH is too high from excess baking soda.

Fix:
Reduce baking soda by −0.1–0.2% OR replace 0.1% soda → 0.3% baking powder.

Check before adjusting:
Hidden acids (cocoa, fruit, brown sugar).

GF note:
Reduce soda earlier in GF systems as GF flours show bitterness sooner than wheat.

Dense/Heavy Crumb

Meaning:
Not enough gas or gas has been trapped by thick batter.

Fix:
Increase baking powder by +0.3–0.5%.

Check before adjusting:
Batter viscosity (too thick traps gas).

GF note:
Density is often hydration, not leavening. Hydrate longer before increasing leaveners.

Rises Then Collapses

Meaning:
Too much gas has built up for the structure of your bake.

Fix:
Reduce baking powder by −0.3–0.5%. Adjust bake time or lower temperature.

Check before adjusting:
Overfilled pans and oven temperature spikes.

GF note:
GF structures fail earlier. Reduce leaveners sooner instead of adding more.

Large Tunnels/Big Holes

Meaning:
Your bake is over-leavened or gas is expanding too fast.

Fix:
Reduce total leavener by −0.3–0.5%, starting with baking powder.

Check before adjusting:
Overmixing or too loose batter.

GF note:
GF batters tunnel at lower leavener levels. Small reductions make large differences.

Flat Cookies (No Spread)

Meaning:
Insufficent soda activity is causing too low of a pH.

Fix:
Increase baking soda by +0.1–0.2% OR reduce baking powder.

Check before adjusting:
Sugar type (white vs brown) and dough temperature

GF note:
Rest GF cookie dough before adjusting soda. Hydration affects spread as much as leavening.

Cookies Spreading Too Much

Meaning:
Too much baking soda or excess sugar/fat.

Fix:
Reduce baking soda by −0.1–0.2%. If lift is needed, add +0.3% baking powder.

Check before adjusting:
Butter temperature and sugar ratio.

GF note:
Chill dough before changing leaveners. GF fats melt faster, exaggerating spread.

Yellow or Greenish Crumb

Meaning:
Too much baking soda in your bake.

Fix:
Reduce soda immediately. Replace using the 3:1 rule (remove 0.1% soda → add 0.3% baking powder).

GF note:
Color defects appear faster in GF systems. Treat it as a hard stop, not a warning.

Gummy/Wet Interior (Quick Breads)

Meaning:
Too much baking soda or acid overload.

Fix:
Reduce baking soda by −0.2%.

Most Popular

A vegan gluten-free lemon almond bundt with a bite taken out on a white plate with more bundts and almonds around

Tips For Healthier Baking

Feb 4, 2026

Ask The Baker

Sensible Edibles is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. This means that if you click on an Amazon link on our site and make a purchase, we may receive a small commission at no additional cost to you. We only recommend products and services that we believe will add value to our readers.